Sam Shepard’s Fool for Love, a century of psychology, and the difference between returning to understand and returning to wait.
By Jill Szoo Wilson
Writer | Theatre Artist | Educator
In Sam Shepard’s Fool for Love, an old man sits in a rocking chair at the edge of a motel room. Eddie and May argue in front of him, talk to him, and sometimes answer him. The audience sees him the whole time. But when a stranger named Martin walks into the room, he never acknowledges the Old Man. Shepard’s stage directions explain why: the Old Man exists only in the minds of Eddie and May.
I can’t think of a better picture of how unfinished business works. It sits in the room with us. It shapes what we say and how we say it. And no one else can see it.
Psychologists have been studying that experience for almost a hundred years. What they found is not quite what we’ve been told.
The Waiter Who Forgot
The research begins with a story about a waiter in a 1920s café. He could keep several tables’ orders in his head without writing anything down, and he never mixed them up. But once a bill was paid, the order was gone. Asked about it a few minutes later, he couldn’t recall it.
No one knows exactly how that afternoon went. The story has been retold too many times. But the observation caught the attention of the psychologist Kurt Lewin. The information in the waiter’s head hadn’t changed. His relationship to it had. While the bill was open, he still needed it. Once it closed, he didn’t.
Lewin believed that every intention creates a kind of tension in the mind, and that the tension holds until the intention is carried out. His student Bluma Zeigarnik set out to test what that tension does to memory. In her main experiment, 32 adults worked through 22 short tasks: winding thread, stringing beads, solving arithmetic problems, drawing. She let them finish about half. On the rest, she stopped them midway, often at the moment they were most absorbed. Afterward, without warning, she asked each person to list every task they could remember.
They recalled the interrupted tasks nearly twice as often as the finished ones. Zeigarnik published the results in 1927, and the Zeigarnik effect entered the language: unfinished things stay with us, and finished things let us go.
Remembering and Returning
The trouble is that the finding didn’t travel well. Other researchers ran similar experiments and got mixed results. Some found the effect. Some found nothing. Some found that people remembered completed tasks better, especially when finishing felt like success. By 1951, the psychologist Carl Hovland observed that few investigators had clearly reproduced Zeigarnik’s results.
In 2025, Romain Ghibellini and Beat Meier of the University of Bern gathered nearly a century of these studies into a single meta-analysis. Their verdict on the famous claim was plain: across the research, unfinished tasks carry no reliable memory advantage. What happened in Zeigarnik’s lab seems to have depended on that lab, on how invested her participants were and how much authority the experimenter held.
But the same analysis confirmed something else. In 1928, another of Lewin’s students, Maria Ovsiankina, asked a different question. She didn’t ask what people remembered. She asked what they did when they had the chance to go back to an interrupted task. Most of them went back. Across the studies Ghibellini and Meier examined, people returned to interrupted tasks about two-thirds of the time. This tendency to resume an interrupted task is known as the Ovsiankina effect.
That is the distinction worth holding onto. We don’t necessarily remember unfinished things better than finished ones. But we do seem to have a tendency to go back to them. The more important finding, it turns out, isn’t what we remember. It’s what we return to.
Telling It Until It’s Finished
Shepard understood return long before the meta-analysis. Fool for Love premiered in 1983 at the Magic Theatre in San Francisco, and its whole structure is a return. May has already left Eddie when the play begins. She has a small life of her own and a date that night with a man named Martin. Eddie drives across the desert to bring her back. And the first thing we see May do, before we know a word of their history, tells us that her leaving didn’t finish anything. When Eddie offers to go outside to get her something, she grabs his leg with both arms and won’t let go.
The history comes out in pieces. Eddie and May fell in love in high school before they learned they had the same father. The Old Man kept two families in two towns and moved between them, and both families learned to wait for him. When the truth came out, Eddie’s mother killed herself with the Old Man’s shotgun. May grew up watching her mother wait for a man who kept leaving. Now she is in love with a man who keeps leaving.
Then Martin arrives, and Shepard does something remarkable. He gives Eddie and May an audience. Eddie tells Martin the story of how he found his father’s other life. May interrupts to tell it her way, as a daughter who watched her mother wait.
One exchange shows how little the telling can do. Eddie insists on finishing his story, and May asks whether he thinks telling it will change anything. He says no. When she asks what the point is, he admits it’s pointless. But he won’t let Martin leave, and he won’t stop. Eddie knows that finishing the story won’t change what happened. What he can’t say is what he hopes finishing it will do.
This is what returning to an unfinished experience actually looks like. Eddie and May aren’t retelling the story because they forgot it. They’re retelling it to settle it: what happened, whose fault it was, and whose version is true. Each is trying to finish the story by telling it right. But when May finally reveals how Eddie’s mother died, the Old Man insists he never knew. Eddie tells him why: he was gone. The man whose choices shaped the lives of everyone in the room wasn’t there to see what became of those choices.
The play ends with Eddie walking out to the parking lot, where his truck and horse trailer are on fire, promising he’ll be right back. May packs her suitcase and leaves, too. We have already seen what happened the last time May left Eddie. Shepard gives us no reason to believe that this departure will be any different.
Most of us do what Eddie does, only without a Martin to listen. A conversation goes badly, and on the drive home you finally know what you should have said. You say it to the windshield. You imagine the other person’s answer, and then your answer to that. Days later, you’re still having the conversation, and the only things that change are the lines. Like Eddie, you know that replaying it won’t change what happened. You replay it anyway.
What a Plan Can Do
The pull of the unfinished has a cost, and in 2011 the psychologists E. J. Masicampo and Roy Baumeister measured it. People with an unfinished goal had intrusive thoughts about it while trying to read a novel. They did worse on an unrelated word puzzle. A goal they weren’t working on was taking up room they needed for the task in front of them.
That cost doesn’t stay in the lab. You can sit across the dinner table from someone you love while they tell you about their day, and part of your attention is still on a conversation from three months ago. You aren’t having that conversation anymore. But it’s still taking some of the attention that belongs to the person in front of you.
Masicampo and Baumeister also found something that helped. When participants wrote a specific plan for the unfinished goal, saying when and how they would work on it, the intrusions faded and their performance recovered. Nothing had been accomplished. Anyone who has lain awake composing an email knows the difference: “I need to answer that” keeps you up, and “I’ll answer it at nine tomorrow” lets you sleep.
The limit of the research matters as much as its promise. Masicampo and Baumeister studied goals people could act on. No one can schedule an apology that never came or a question no one will answer. Eddie can’t put his father’s absence on a calendar. When there’s no plan to make, we do what Eddie does: we tell the story again. Those situations need a different kind of decision.
Unfinished, or Still Ours to Finish
Something can be unfinished without there being anything left for us to do. Those are two different conditions, and much of our suffering comes from confusing them.
If I have hurt someone, I can apologize. If I don’t understand something, I can ask. If a relationship is worth repairing, I can try. Those are mine to do. But I cannot make anyone accept the apology, answer the question, or meet me halfway. At some point I may have done everything that was mine to do, and the thing I wanted still hasn’t happened. The story is unfinished. My part of it is not.
That is May’s problem. She has already done what was hers to do: she left. But she is still waiting for Eddie to become the man who stays, the man her father never was. As long as her ending depends on Eddie’s choice, leaving can’t finish anything. She can walk out of the motel room. The question is whether she can live her life without waiting for Eddie to become someone he has never been.
None of this means we stop thinking about what happened to us. I have reread the same plays for decades, and they keep changing because I keep changing. Something I understood one way at twenty-five means something else at forty-five. The words haven’t moved. I have. Our own histories work the same way, and returning to them to understand them better is one of the gifts of a long life.
But there is a difference between returning to understand and returning to wait. One asks, “What can I see now that I couldn’t see then?” The other asks the same question it asked ten years ago and waits for someone else to answer it.
Leaving the Room
Shepard ends his play with an image that won’t leave me. Eddie and May are gone. Martin stands at the window watching the fire outside, and the Old Man returns to his rocking chair, still gazing at the woman of his dreams in a picture that isn’t there. Shepard hasn’t given us two people who can’t let go of the past. He has given us three. The play stops there. It never tells us whether Eddie and May learn to live without him.
Our lives don’t stop there. They go on after we leave the room. There are people across the table from us now, conversations we want to hear, and work we haven’t made yet. We will carry our histories into all of it, and we wouldn’t want to lose them. They are part of who we are. But something can belong to our story without being the thing our attention is organized around.
The waiter in the café had the advantage of knowing when he was finished. His customers paid their bills, and there were other people waiting to be served. We don’t always get that kind of ending. Sometimes we have to decide that our part is done while knowing there are things about the story we may never understand. We may even return to it from time to time and discover something we couldn’t see before.
Returning to a story that belongs to us is not the same as waiting for someone else to finish it so that we can get on with ours.
We may never get to finish some of the things we wanted to finish. But we can still be finished with them.
Further Reading
- Shepard, S. (1983). Fool for Love. Play information
- Zeigarnik, B. (1927). Das Behalten erledigter und unerledigter Handlungen [The retention of completed and uncompleted actions]. Psychologische Forschung, 9, 1–85. English translation
- MacLeod, C. M. (2020). Zeigarnik and von Restorff: The memory effects and the stories behind them. Memory & Cognition, 48, 1073–1088. Read the article
- Ghibellini, R., & Meier, B. (2025). Interruption, recall and resumption: A meta-analysis of the Zeigarnik and Ovsiankina effects. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 12, Article 962. Read the article
- Masicampo, E. J., & Baumeister, R. F. (2011). Consider it done! Plan making can eliminate the cognitive effects of unfulfilled goals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 101(4), 667–683. Read the abstract




Leave a Reply